Andrew Janssen wrote: > Jefferson wrote: >>Juha Vesanto wrote: >>>Andrew Janssen wrote: >>> >>>>>The eastern forces were able to get ahead of the Ice Demons on the >>>>>*western* side of the Tavar Mountains that form the north-south spine >>> >>>Err... wait a minute. Where did it say that? >> >>That was me. >> >>>I'm willing to >>>let that stand, if there is reason to, but it is unclear to me >>>where, and how, did the western army manage to cut off the advance of >>>the Ice Demons in Tana? The way I see it, all major action happened >>>in Parglug. >> >>>It's just that I'll have to rewrite the events for this year if this >>>was the case. Which is something I can do, but would rather not. >> >>Something good needs to happen in Tana to justify Exquaestio's 'Mixed >>Results.' I don't insist that the allies got ahead of the demons, but if >>nothing good happened in Parglug that wouldn't be mixed results, that would >>be failure. > > Actually, Jeff, looking back at the action results I think you've been > confusing your east with your west. Nope. > The original action result for Exquaestio was: > >>---+++ Action 1-3: The Third Demon War >> >>*Resolution:* Diff = Normal (0) + Dice (---+) + Extras (Triple: +2) = 0 >>Mixed results >> >>*Dice:* >> >> * Casualties: -1 >> * Reputation: -1 >> * East: -1 >> * West: +1 > > The success in the west would represent the success of the Allied Army > in destroying the horde at Parglug. The failure in the east would be the > failure of the battle at Lildra to slow the Ice Demon advance north. Yes, the contribution in the east was negative, and the contribution in the west was positive. However, _the result_ was Mixed and, overall, Exquaestio got nothing from the west and was destroyed in the east. Overall, that's a failure. Now, we could remove Lildra and have Exquaestio take fewer casualties, but its a good story and that wouldn't explain the extra resources Exquaestio allotted to this action. Considering the relative numbers involved its much easier to explain something positive resulting in the east than in the west. The destruction of Exquaestio's rohain and guards to some benefit in the east while having no significant effect in the west explains: The extra resources allocated to the action. The result dice. The overall result. And any alternative also needs to consider all three of these to make sense. Jefferson http://www.picotech.net/~jeff_wilson63/rpg/Exq_Main.html ---------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, send mail to celandra-off@phoenyx.net.
