Home | Forum | Unread | Sign in | Sign in | Beta? | Wiki
The Phoenyx
your roleplaying community

discussion > gamers > main

GAMERS is about roleplaying games (including sims) and almost anything of interest to the average roleplayer.
Subscribe | Unread | Recent | Group options | Topic options | Post
MichaelWShaffer
Michael W. Shaffer

Fri

Jun 22
2001

03:31



Wikify

Helping aspiring GMs

I have to disagree that a GM should start with a more complex game system.
If she's trying to concentrate on GMing, why complicate that with having to
remember a lot of rules as well?  The best way to be a good GM is to just do
it and learn from your experience.

I don't buy the complex rules support a beginning GM argument.  GMing isn't
about rules as much as about running a game, providing a campaign, ruling
whether a PC can do something.  I don't think you need rules for this.  In
fact, I believe the fewer rules, the more realistic the campaign setting
will be.  If you have to use common sense in creating your campaign world
rather than fitting it into a rules system, I think it will come out better.
In my opinion a campaign world created without reference to any rules
system, perhaps as if it were being created as a setting for a novel, will
probably be better for it.

Pookey 

on 6/21/01 7:38 PM, shadoe@kscable.com at shadoe@kscable.com wrote:

> It probably be best to use something a bit more spelled out like D&D3E or
> some such.  Unless she feels very adventurous I recommend a system she is
> comfortable playing.  That way she doesn't learn the rules as she run the
> game.  It tends to bog a game down when the GM is constantly looking up
> stuff.
> And as much as I dislike modules and such, a canned adventure may be very
> useful.  It one less thing to worry about for a starting GM.
> 
> Rolando
> Who learned to run GURPS the hard way!
> 
> On Thursday, June 21, 2001 11:42 AM, Joel Arellano
> [SMTP:joelarellano@hotmail.com] wrote:
> | Thanks. Pretty much what I said to her.
> |
> | I'm wondering if I should advise her to game-master a rules-light system
> | like Fudge, or something slightly more complex like GURPS, the FUZION
> | system, or D&D 3e. (We currently play in a fantasy campaign using the 3e
> | rules.) I'm leaning towards the latter so she will have "support" from
> the
> | rules until she gets use to "winging it."
> |
> | Joel

-- 
Michael W. Shaffer
PGPKey: 0x253E28F3
http://www.geocities.com/pookey_shaffer/pookey.html


----------------------------------------------------------------
GMAST Home Page:  http://www.phoenyx.net/gmast/

Subject (required)




 
Refresh