Home | Forum | Unread | Sign in | Sign in | Beta? | Wiki
The Phoenyx
your roleplaying community

discussion > gamers > main

GAMERS is about roleplaying games (including sims) and almost anything of interest to the average roleplayer.
Subscribe | Unread | Recent | Group options | Topic options | Post
KarenCravens
Karen Cravens

Tue

Dec 20
2005

02:58



Wikify

Paradox four: roleplaying is a male game.

On Mon, 19 Dec 2005, Roger Burton West wrote:

RBW>If I'm understanding you correctly, would it be fair to say that one of
RBW>the canonical "female stories" in this sense is the romance plot? (As
RBW>distinct from the subplots one tends to see in action films, in which
RBW>the female lead has a gender-ambiguous name and argues incessantly with
RBW>the male lead...)

That's one, at least.

I suppose, if I follow my own analogy, "female stories" should involve 
whatever pop-fic women read.  Which, if I take my mother as a test case, 
also involves things like Janet Evanovich and so forth.  Now, Googling on 
that, I find a lot of that classified under "romance" (which IIRC it 
isn't, but maybe "romance" means "women's fiction" in those cases) but 
mostly it's "mystery/thriller."  I'd throw in "humor," having read a few 
of them while staying at Mom's.  (Until she moved back to town this 
summer, she lived four hours away, so I'd take our son down there 
periodically so she could get her grandchild fix.)

Of course, in poking around on the net, I find that Evanovich is described 
as "a former romance writer" so maybe that's the reason for the 
classification.

RBW>I ask because I like the idea of a romance-based RPG as a change of pace
RBW>from the basically action- and investigation-centred games that I tend
RBW>to run. I haven't seen _Blue Rose_, but reviews have been very mixed and
RBW>it sounds pretty fluffy; what I'd really like to see is something to
RBW>support multiple romantic genres, for example a Regency game in the
RBW>style of Georgette Heyer.

Well, the Evanovich stuff, and plenty of other stuff like it, is basically 
action- and investigation-centered.  It's just that the action is gentler, 
and the investigation is really a sideline.

I'd have to analyze it more (and I don't remember any specifics well 
enough just now), but I'd tentatively say the stories are more about the 
predicaments the heroine gets into.  Sometimes the mysteries get solved 
serendipitously (q.v. especially any book with a cat on the cover, 
especially if the cat's name is part of the series).

I'm not really sure any of that would translate well to a roleplaying 
game, at least one I'd be interested in playing.  I do admit I like that 
sort of book, if I'm in the mood for lite-n-fluffy reading, though I 
rarely have time.

RBW>A big part of the problem, I suspect, would be in finding the players;
RBW>most of the people who'd enjoy a game like this probably aren't already
RBW>gamers.

That's the thing... I've never really been able to explain to anyone how 
to attract more women gamers, because I'm really not one.  (And yes, I'm 
straight.  I *said* it was a paradox...)

-- 
Karen J. Cravens  silver@phoenyx.net

----------------------------------------------------------------
GAMERS Home Page:  http://www.phoenyx.net/gamers/

Subject (required)




 
Refresh