Home | Forum | Unread | Sign in | Sign in | Beta? | Wiki
The Phoenyx
your roleplaying community

news > managers > main

Discussion, mostly technical, about running Phoenyx groups goes here. Hypotheticals and wishlists go in stakeholders.
Subscribe | Unread | Recent | Group options | Topic options | Post
TimHall
Tim Hall

Thu

Jun 17
2004

07:07Z

MGR: AARRGH!

Status reporter for kalyr wrote:

>0 spam message discarded from 207.159.120.61 (Re: Kalyr: 94c - To The City)

The IP address matches nn7.excitenetwork.com [207.159.120.61]

I have a very nasty suspicion this is a false positive, caused by that
player with earlier upper/lower case problems.
-- --------------------------------------------------------------
Game(s): Kalyr
Listowner tools are found at http://www.phoenyx.net/listowners/

KarenCravens
Karen Cravens

Thu

Jun 17
2004

14:08Z

MGR: AARRGH!

On Thu, 17 Jun 2004, Tim Hall wrote:

TH>I have a very nasty suspicion this is a false positive, caused by that
TH>player with earlier upper/lower case problems.

I'm looking at that in the spamtrap, and the brightly-colored
HTML-"enhanced" Excite-added sig-ad is twice the size of the message.

Which is to say, looks like the spamfilter works just fine.  I don't see
why the Phoenyx should be expected to distribute ads just because they're
piggybacking on a member post.

-- --------------------------------------------------------------
Game(s): The Whole Phoenyx
Listowner tools are found at http://www.phoenyx.net/listowners/

TimHall
Tim Hall

Thu

Jun 17
2004

17:09Z

MGR: AARRGH!

Karen J. Cravens wrote:

>I'm looking at that in the spamtrap, and the brightly-colored
>HTML-"enhanced" Excite-added sig-ad is twice the size of the message.

Is Excite sending html only email? If it refuses to send text-only
email that fits my definition of broken.  It may be a configuration
setting the user can change.  Any other GMs out there got players
using excite?  Are there any problems with them?

>Which is to say, looks like the spamfilter works just fine.  I don't see
>why the Phoenyx should be expected to distribute ads just because they're
>piggybacking on a member post.

I've asked him to resend it, cc-ed to me, so I can repost the thing to
the list shorn of the gunk excite adds.

I don't know of a tactful way of telling my player "Your free email
provider blows chunks, please switch to something else that doesn't
suck quite as much".  

I really *don't* want to lose the player altogether.
-- --------------------------------------------------------------
Game(s): Kalyr
Listowner tools are found at http://www.phoenyx.net/listowners/

Chuk
Chuk Goodin

Thu

Jun 17
2004

17:35Z

MGR: AARRGH!

On Thu, Jun 17, 2004 at 12:09:28PM -0500, Tim Hall wrote:
> I don't know of a tactful way of telling my player "Your free email
> provider blows chunks, please switch to something else that doesn't
> suck quite as much".  

Personally, I would say "Your free email provider sucks rocks, please 
switch to something else that doesn't blow quite as much."

I have to do this all the time at work.

-- --------------------------------------------------------------
Game(s): Alien Light
Listowner tools are found at http://www.phoenyx.net/listowners/

ErisReddoch
Eris Reddoch

Thu

Jun 17
2004

18:27Z

MGR: AARRGH!

Chuk Goodin wrote:

>  On Thu, Jun 17, 2004 at 12:09:28PM -0500, Tim Hall wrote:
>
> > I don't know of a tactful way of telling my player "Your free email
> > provider blows chunks, please switch to something else that
> > doesn't suck quite as much".
>
>  Personally, I would say "Your free email provider sucks rocks, please
>  switch to something else that doesn't blow quite as much."

Yeah, I would, too, and I'd offer a suggestion or two for a replacement. 
Yahoomail and hotmail seem to be acceptable, barely. Neither of them 
have *too* much space eaten by junk ads, as long as they are limited to 
plain text only.

Karen, is it outside the realm of the possible for phoenyx to set up a 
webmail interface, like SquirrelMail, Horde, or some sort of online 
"form mail" interface of your own design? If you did, players could post 
to the lists even when they didn't have access to popmail, and wouldn't 
have to use those "ad carriers." Any interface like that would have to 
be password protected and limited to only list members posting, of 
course, but it really might get some of the players off of things like 
excite.  Personally, I'm not a big fan of forums and webmail type 
interfaces, but I know some folks do like them, and those sort of 
interfaces can almost always be accessed *anywhere* a person has access 
to the web.

Eris
-- --------------------------------------------------------------
Game(s): erisred@bellsouth.net
Listowner tools are found at http://www.phoenyx.net/listowners/

KarenCravens
Karen Cravens

Thu

Jun 17
2004

20:25Z

MGR: AARRGH!

On Thu, 17 Jun 2004, Eris Reddoch wrote:

ER>Yeah, I would, too, and I'd offer a suggestion or two for a replacement.
ER>Yahoomail and hotmail seem to be acceptable, barely. Neither of them
ER>have *too* much space eaten by junk ads, as long as they are limited to
ER>plain text only.

Some of them are stripped by the Phoenyx, but there again it doesn't
happen until after spamchecking.

ER>Karen, is it outside the realm of the possible for phoenyx to set up a
ER>webmail interface, like SquirrelMail, Horde, or some sort of online
ER>"form mail" interface of your own design? If you did, players could post
ER>to the lists even when they didn't have access to popmail, and wouldn't
ER>have to use those "ad carriers." Any interface like that would have to
ER>be password protected and limited to only list members posting, of
ER>course, but it really might get some of the players off of things like
ER>excite.  Personally, I'm not a big fan of forums and webmail type
ER>interfaces, but I know some folks do like them, and those sort of
ER>interfaces can almost always be accessed *anywhere* a person has access
ER>to the web.

Say, I'll be you haven't been reading my blog.



-- --------------------------------------------------------------
Game(s): The Whole Phoenyx
Listowner tools are found at http://www.phoenyx.net/listowners/

ErisReddoch
Eris Reddoch

Thu

Jun 17
2004

22:06Z

MGR: AARRGH!

Karen J. Cravens wrote:

> ER>Karen, is it outside the realm of the possible for phoenyx to set up a
> ER>webmail interface, like SquirrelMail, Horde, or some sort of online
> ER>"form mail" interface of your own design? If you did, players could post
> ER>to the lists even when they didn't have access to popmail, and wouldn't
> ER>have to use those "ad carriers." Any interface like that would have to
> ER>be password protected and limited to only list members posting, of
> ER>course, but it really might get some of the players off of things like
> ER>excite.  Personally, I'm not a big fan of forums and webmail type
> ER>interfaces, but I know some folks do like them, and those sort of
> ER>interfaces can almost always be accessed *anywhere* a person has access
> ER>to the web.
> 
> Say, I'll be you haven't been reading my blog.

No, I haven't. Should I have been? Does this mean you've 
given the complete kabosh to the idea of "webmail", or have 
news of its imminent appearance on phoenyx? 

Eris
-- --------------------------------------------------------------
Game(s): erisred@bellsouth.net
Listowner tools are found at http://www.phoenyx.net/listowners/

KarenCravens
Karen Cravens

Fri

Jun 18
2004

00:38Z

MGR: AARRGH!

On Thu, 17 Jun 2004, Eris Reddoch wrote:

ER>No, I haven't. Should I have been? Does this mean you've
ER>given the complete kabosh to the idea of "webmail", or have
ER>news of its imminent appearance on phoenyx? 

Anybody who's interested in the future software probably should at least
check it once in awhile.

Easiest way to read past stuff right now is (probably) the NNTP server:
news://phoenyx.net/

The mostly-reliable way to read it on a current basis is the Bryar blog
software, which includes an RSS feed if you use an aggregator (I'm
currently using Bloglines, and there's a link on the bottom of the page):

http://www.phoenyx.net/gamehawk/bryar.cgi

It's also more or less a Wiki (less, at the moment), so you can also
generally get to the pages with a bit of manual URL-tweaking:

http://www.phoenyx.net/tools/wiki/gamehawk/1-all
http://www.phoenyx.net/tools/wiki/gamehawk/2-all
und so weiter.

And lastly, you can subscribe it as a mailing list if you register on the
web (email registration is still in alpha):

http://www.phoenyx.net/tools/register

and then send mail to join+gamehawk@ here.

The plethora of ways to read the content is because the "blog" is actually
a Gamehawk (successor to Firehawk) group, with thread-starting posts
("blog entries") restricted to me and replies ("comments") open to
anybody.  And that probably answers your question without you having to
actually go read it...


-- --------------------------------------------------------------
Game(s): The Whole Phoenyx
Listowner tools are found at http://www.phoenyx.net/listowners/

Chuk
Chuk Goodin

Fri

Jun 18
2004

16:19Z

MGR: AARRGH!

On Thu, Jun 17, 2004 at 07:38:19PM -0500, Karen J. Cravens wrote:
> Easiest way to read past stuff right now is (probably) the NNTP server:
> news://phoenyx.net/

That doesn't seem to work for me.  I get some truly weird error messages 
with trn.

-- --------------------------------------------------------------
Game(s): Alien Light
Listowner tools are found at http://www.phoenyx.net/listowners/

KarenCravens
Karen Cravens

Fri

Jun 18
2004

16:35Z

MGR: AARRGH!

On Fri, 18 Jun 2004, Chuk Goodin wrote:

CG>That doesn't seem to work for me.  I get some truly weird error messages
CG>with trn.

Looking at the session, it looks like trn relies on extended NNTP commands
and either completely ignores Gamehawk's list of what is supported, or
else Gamehawk isn't being clear enough about what it does.  But it gives
me something to go on, anyway.  Thanks.

-- --------------------------------------------------------------
Game(s): The Whole Phoenyx
Listowner tools are found at http://www.phoenyx.net/listowners/

KarenCravens
Karen Cravens

Fri

Jun 18
2004

17:07Z

MGR: AARRGH!

On Fri, 18 Jun 2004, Karen J. Cravens wrote:

KJC>Looking at the session, it looks like trn relies on extended NNTP commands
KJC>and either completely ignores Gamehawk's list of what is supported, or
KJC>else Gamehawk isn't being clear enough about what it does.  But it gives
KJC>me something to go on, anyway.  Thanks.

Okay, I dissected it in a post to gamehawk+nntp, but the main problem
seems to be that the early posts aren't really RFC-compliant yet (they're
Bryar-only posts).  They confuse the heck out of XNews, too.  Read those
via the web interface, and look at the later messages (after "I'm a
mailing list!") in trn.  There's still some stuff that trn is being
obstinate about (it doesn't seem capable of connecting to RFC-977
servers), but there shouldn't be anything fatal after those early posts.

-- --------------------------------------------------------------
Game(s): The Whole Phoenyx
Listowner tools are found at http://www.phoenyx.net/listowners/

KarenCravens
Karen Cravens

Sat

Jun 19
2004

05:23Z

MGR: AARRGH!

On Fri, 18 Jun 2004, Chuk Goodin wrote:

CG>That doesn't seem to work for me.  I get some truly weird error messages
CG>with trn.

Okay, now I've taught Gamehawk some more extended-NNTP.  Hopefully most of
the truly weirdness was the early wacky messages, though.

-- --------------------------------------------------------------
Game(s): The Whole Phoenyx
Listowner tools are found at http://www.phoenyx.net/listowners/

KarenCravens
Karen Cravens

Thu

Jun 17
2004

20:24Z

MGR: AARRGH!

On Thu, 17 Jun 2004, Tim Hall wrote:

TH>Is Excite sending html only email? If it refuses to send text-only
TH>email that fits my definition of broken.  It may be a configuration
TH>setting the user can change.  Any other GMs out there got players
TH>using excite?  Are there any problems with them?

No, it's sending both... the ad in the text version is only slightly
longer than the message.  But the spamcheck happens first thing.

That'll change once we switch over to the whitelisted version.  I'm still
ambivalent on whether we'll spamcheck whitelisted posts... they could
still be forgeries, but like as not those will be virus-attachment posts.

TH>I don't know of a tactful way of telling my player "Your free email
TH>provider blows chunks, please switch to something else that doesn't
TH>suck quite as much".

Is there some problem with him sending directly?  Surely he could still
put his excite address on it or, failing that, you can set your list to
rewrite addresses/

TH>I really *don't* want to lose the player altogether.

No, I wouldn't think so.

-- --------------------------------------------------------------
Game(s): The Whole Phoenyx
Listowner tools are found at http://www.phoenyx.net/listowners/

Subject (required)